Vick or Kolb?

[starbuck]

are the Eagles in a unique position or what? they don't know which QB to start, not because they don't have a good qb but because both are playing so good.

[Biggin]

If I was Andy Reid, both guys would see reps.

Kolb is playing very well right now, I would get Vick 10-12 reps a game at first.

If Kolb drops off or plays bad, Vick takes over.

its such a tricky situation.
you always wanna go with the hot hand, but you also want a QB to be the leader and be counted on and have the team behind them.

going back and forth has never really worked. but its hard not to let Vick see the field when he was playing so well.

BUT......DeSean Jackson took a hit today and who knows how long he is out. He is their best weapon and playmaker, so its not fair to judge either QB with him not at 100%.

[1inStripes]

I thought Kolb sucked Biggin?

[Biggin]

do I think he is great?
nah

has he been playing well?
yeah

would i take him over DM?
no

[Biggin]

ill put it this way

I think Kolb is the better passer. BUt he does have his shortcomings. Not great accuracy, not very steady in the pocket, etc..
But I think Vick, an inferior passer, has a better relationship with the WRs and is a better leader.

[Milk3]

I say Vick. He's very diverse.